PrivacyPick

Private Internet Access vs Surfshark Comparison

Feature
Overview
Rating
7.7
8.0
Pricing
  • $11.95/mo1 month
  • $3.99/mo1 year
  • $2.03/mo3 years + 4 months
Show billing details
  • 1 month: Billed monthly, no discount; PIA's pricing page states it autorenews at $11.95 a month
  • 1 year: $47.88 for the first year; PIA's pricing page states it then autorenews annually at the same $47.88
  • 3 years + 4 months: $81.20 for the first 40 months (4 bonus months included); PIA's pricing page states it then autorenews at $81.20 every 3 years ($2.26/mo)
  • $16.45/moStarter, 1 month
  • $3.39/moStarter, 1 year
  • $2.49/moStarter, 2 years
Show billing details
  • Starter, 1 month: Billed monthly, no discount
  • Starter, 1 year: Intro rate for the first 12 months (+3 bonus months); renews at $79/yr (~$6.58/mo) per Surfshark's billing-terms page
  • Starter, 2 years: Intro rate for the first 24 months (+3 bonus months); renews at $79/yr (~$6.58/mo, 1-year term) per Surfshark's billing-terms page
Established20102018
Platforms
WindowsmacOSLinuxAndroidiOS
WindowsmacOSLinuxAndroidiOS
Rating by category
No-Logs Audit & Trust
7.5
7.5
Security Features
8.0
8.5
Speed & Reliability
7.0
8.0
Price & Value
9.0
8.5
Support & Usability
7.5
8.0
Privacy
No-logs auditDeloitte Audit Romania 2025
Show audit details

Third Deloitte limited-assurance engagement under ISAE 3000 (Revised), signed December 19, 2025 and covering PIA's systems as of October 31, 2025: VPN and distribution servers checked against PIA's description of its no-logs safeguards, plus user access, change, configuration and incident management and the dedicated-IP token system. The report can be downloaded from PIA's site without an account. Earlier Deloitte engagements date from 2022 and 2024. Beyond the audits, PIA's no-logs claim has been tested in two documented US court cases (a 2016 FBI investigation and a 2018 federal hacking trial) where subpoenas produced no user data.

KPMG 2026
Show audit details

Reasonable assurance report under ISAE 3000 (Revised) on the design and implementation of the controls behind Surfshark's no-logs VPN service as at 30 October 2026, dated 9 November 2026. The report was ordered by Surfshark's group company Netflow, UAB. Surfshark says KPMG checked that VPN servers keep no activity or connection logs after login, that temporary login data is deleted within a set time, and how usage analytics, configuration changes and privileged staff access are handled. The report opens on Surfshark's site after accepting KPMG's terms, without an account. Deloitte carried out earlier no-logs assurance engagements in 2023 and 2025; those reports are available only after logging in.

JurisdictionUnited StatesNetherlands
Anonymous accountsNoNo
Network
Servers113 countries, 180 locations
Show details

PIA's figure, including all 50 US states. PIA does not publish a total server count, and some locations are virtual: the India location, for example, uses hardware in Singapore.

4,500+ servers
Show details

100 countries.

Protocols
WireGuardOpenVPN
WireGuardOpenVPNIKEv2Dausos (macOS only)
DevicesUnlimitedUnlimited
Features
Kill switchYesYes
Split tunnelingYesYes
Torrenting allowedYesYes
Double VPNNot specifiedYes
Rotating IPNot specifiedYes
Streaming unblockNot specifiedNot specified
ReviewRead more →Read more →

Where each one is ahead

Private Internet Access

No clear advantage in the compared rows.

Surfshark

  • Speed & Reliability: rated 8.0 vs 7.0

Read also

Missing an app?

Tell us what you could not find. Every suggestion goes onto our list of products to review.

This opens a message in your email app, addressed to hello@privacypick.com. Nothing is sent until you press send there.