PrivacyPick

Posteo vs StartMail Comparison

Feature
Overview
Rating
6.1
6.5
Pricing
  • $1.00/moStandard (individual, monthly)
Show billing details
  • Standard (individual, monthly): EUR 1/month, prepaid credit (minimum top-up EUR 12, maximum EUR 120)
  • $4.99/moPersonal (annual)
  • $6.99/moBusiness (annual)
Show billing details
  • Personal (annual): $59.88/year
  • Business (annual): $83.88/year
Free tierPaid onlyPaid only
Established20092013
PlatformsNot specified
AndroidiOS
Rating by category
Security
6.0
6.5
Privacy & Trust
7.3
7.0
Features
4.5
6.5
Usability
4.5
5.5
Price & Value
7.5
6.5
Privacy
JurisdictionGermany
Show details

Posteo e.K. (a registered sole proprietorship), Methfesselstr. 38, 10965 Berlin. Registered at the Handelsregister Berlin-Charlottenburg, HRA 47592 B. Founded and owned by Patrik and Sabrina Löhr, self-financed with no external investors or debt.

Netherlands
Show details

StartMail B.V., registered in Zeist, Netherlands. Servers are company-owned hardware in locked cabinets inside Dutch data centers — not third-party cloud infrastructure.

Independent security auditCure53 2017
Show audit details

Posteo web application, including Calendar and Notes (a separate, earlier Cure53 test in April 2015 covered Crypto Mail Storage specifically)

None on record
Source codePartly open sourceClosed source
Zero-access encryptionYesNo
Intra-provider E2EENoNo
External PGPNativeNative
Past data breachNoNo
TelemetryNo telemetryOn unless you opt out
Features
HostingCloudCloud
Custom domain supportNoYes
AliasesLimitedUnlimited
Anti-spam approachDescribed by Posteo only as a 'highly efficient spam and virus filter' — no further technical methodology is publicly documented.Personal, per-user Bayesian spam filter (SpamAssassin) trained by the user marking mail as spam or not; the training data is stored inside that user's own encrypted vault rather than pooled across the service.
Bundled services
CalendarAddress BookNotes
Not specified
ReviewRead more →Read more →

Where each one is ahead

Posteo

  • Price & Value: rated 7.5 vs 6.5
  • Independent security audit: Cure53 (2017)
  • Zero-access encryption: Yes
  • Telemetry: No telemetry

StartMail

  • Features: rated 6.5 vs 4.5
  • Usability: rated 5.5 vs 4.5
  • Custom domain support: Yes
  • Aliases: Unlimited

Read also

Missing an app?

Tell us what you could not find. Every suggestion goes onto our list of products to review.

This opens a message in your email app, addressed to hello@privacypick.com. Nothing is sent until you press send there.