PrivacyPick

1Password vs Google Password Manager Comparison

Feature
Overview
Rating
8.5
5.3
Pricing
  • $3.99/moIndividual (annual)
  • $5.99/moFamilies (up to 6 users, annual)
Show billing details
  • Individual (annual): $47.88/year
  • Families (up to 6 users, annual): $71.88/year
Not specified
Free tierPaid onlyFree tier
Established20052015
Platforms
WindowsmacOSLinuxAndroidiOSBrowser extensionCLI
WindowsmacOSLinuxAndroidiOS
Rating by category
Security
9.5
5.5
Privacy & Trust
7.5
1.5
Features
9.0
5.5
Usability & Platforms
9.0
8.5
Price & Value
6.5
9.0
Security
Independent security auditIndependent Security Evaluators 2020
Show audit details

Penetration test and code review of the 1Password system

None on record
Source codeClosed sourcePartly open source
EncryptionAES-256-GCM, Secret Key + PBKDF2
Show details

Data is encrypted with AES-GCM-256. The vault key is derived from your account password using PBKDF2-HMAC-SHA256 at 650,000 iterations, then combined with a 128-bit Secret Key that never leaves your devices — so an attacker who guesses the password alone still cannot decrypt anything. Authentication uses SRP, so password-equivalent data is never sent to the server.

Google-held key by default
Show details

Passwords are encrypted in transit and storage, but by default the key sits in your Google Account; on-device encryption, once set up, leaves the key with you only and cannot be removed. Passkeys are always end-to-end encrypted, unlocked with a screen lock or a Google Password Manager PIN.

Vault 2FATOTP + hardware keysNone
Second-secret modelYesNo
Past data breachNoNo
TelemetryOn unless you opt outOn unless you opt out
Features
HostingCloudCloud
PasskeysStores + unlocksStores + unlocks
Built-in email aliasesYesNot specified
Company
OwnerAgileBits Inc.
Show details

AgileBits Inc., a Canadian company headquartered in Toronto, Ontario. Venture-funded — Accel and ICONIQ Growth both hold board seats. Founded 2005; roughly 1,400 employees.

Google LLC
Show details

A feature of Google Accounts, Chrome and Android rather than a separate product; the data controller named in Google's privacy policy is Google LLC, Mountain View, California.

ReviewRead more →Read more →

Where each one is ahead

1Password

  • Privacy & Trust: rated 7.5 vs 1.5
  • Security: rated 9.5 vs 5.5
  • Independent security audit: Independent Security Evaluators (2020)
  • Vault 2FA: TOTP + hardware keys
  • Second-secret model: Yes

Google Password Manager

  • Price & Value: rated 9.0 vs 6.5
  • Free tier: Free tier

Read also

Missing an app?

Tell us what you could not find. Every suggestion goes onto our list of products to review.

This opens a message in your email app, addressed to hello@privacypick.com. Nothing is sent until you press send there.