PrivacyPick

Electrum vs Monero GUI Comparison

Feature
Overview
Rating
7.3
7.5
TypeSoftware walletSoftware wallet
PriceNot specifiedNot specified
Free to useYesYes
Established20112016
Platforms
WindowsmacOSLinuxAndroid
WindowsmacOSLinux
Networks
BitcoinLightning
Monero
Rating by category
Key Custody & Recovery
7.5
7.5
Network & Metadata Privacy
6.5
7.0
Security & Transparency
7.0
7.0
Usability & Chain Support
7.0
7.0
Price & Value
9.5
10.0
Keys & recovery
Who holds the keysYou hold the keys
Show details

Electrum creates its own seed phrase: 12 words from the same 2048-word list as BIP39, but with a version number hidden in the phrase's hash instead of a BIP39 checksum, so a wallet that reads only BIP39 phrases cannot restore it. Electrum publishes the format, and it can also restore BIP39 phrases and SLIP-39 shares.

You hold the keys
Show details

Monero's own 25-word seed: 24 words encode the private spend key and the 25th is a checksum. It is not BIP39, but it is the most widely used seed format among Monero wallets. The GUI creates and restores only this format, and can also restore a wallet from its private keys or from a hardware wallet.

Seed formatOwn formatOwn format
Seed portabilityLimited outside this walletRestores in other wallets
PassphraseYesYes
RecoverySeed phraseSeed phrase
MultisigBuilt inNot supported
Network & metadata
Default serverPublic serversPublic servers
Own nodeSupportedSupported
TorThrough a proxy you set upThrough a proxy you set up
Coin controlFullNone
ID for in-app buyingNoNo
Device purchaseNot applicableNot applicable
Device
Secure elementNot applicableNot applicable
Air-gappedNot applicableNot applicable
Firmware codeNot applicableNot applicable
Trust & transparency
App codeFully open sourceFully open source
Server codeFully open sourceNo vendor servers
Reproducible buildsYesYes
Security auditNone on recordNone on record
Bug bountyNoYes
JurisdictionGermany
Show details

Electrum Technologies GmbH, Berlin, develops and distributes the software and hosts electrum.org. The company holds no user accounts and cannot freeze or reverse payments. Anyone can run an Electrum server, and none of the 84 servers in the app's built-in list is on electrum.org.

No legal entity
Show details

The Monero Project calls itself a loose collective of individuals; the GUI has no company behind it. The terms of use of getmonero.org, last revised in June 2017, are governed by the laws of South Africa.

OwnerElectrum Technologies GmbH
Show details

Thomas Voegtlin created Electrum in November 2011 and founded Electrum Technologies GmbH in 2013. Two developers, Thomas Voegtlin and SomberNight, have write access to the code; website changes and releases must be signed by both.

The Monero Project
Show details

Built by volunteer and crowdfunded contributors under the oversight of the Monero Core Team. No part of the block reward goes to development; the project is funded by donations to its General Fund and through the Community Crowdfunding System.

TelemetryOpt-inNo telemetry
Past incidentYesYes
ReviewRead more →Read more →

Where each one is ahead

Electrum

  • Multisig: Built in
  • Coin control: Full

Monero GUI

  • Seed portability: Restores in other wallets
  • Bug bounty: Yes
  • Telemetry: No telemetry

Read also

Missing an app?

Tell us what you could not find. Every suggestion goes onto our list of products to review.

This opens a message in your email app, addressed to hello@privacypick.com. Nothing is sent until you press send there.