PrivacyPick

Element vs Signal Comparison

Feature
Overview
Rating
6.6
8.2
PricingNot specifiedNot specified
Free tierFree tierFree tier
EstablishedNot specifiedNot specified
Platforms
AndroidiOSWindowsmacOSLinux
WindowsmacOSLinuxAndroidiOS
Rating by category
Cryptography & Protocol
7.0
9.5
Metadata Privacy
4.5
6.5
Transparency & Verifiability
7.5
8.5
Usability & Reach
7.5
8.0
Funding & Sustainability
7.5
8.5
Encryption
E2EE by defaultAll chatsAll chats
Group chat E2EESome groupsAll groups
ProtocolOlm / Megolm
Show details

Olm, an implementation of the Double Ratchet, protects the keys sent between devices; Megolm, a group ratchet, encrypts the messages in a room. Megolm gives only partial forward secrecy and no post-compromise security, according to its own specification.

Signal protocol
Show details

Double Ratchet with PQXDH, a post-quantum key agreement (September 2023); a Sparse Post-Quantum Ratchet added on top was announced in October 2025

Forward secrecyNoYes
Post-compromise securityNoYes
Identity & metadata
Sign-up needsEmail addressPhone number
Metadata protectionStandard
Show details

Users are identified by a Matrix ID of the form @name:server. In an encrypted room the homeserver still stores the room name, topic and membership in plaintext and knows who sent each message and when. Every server taking part in a federated room keeps a copy of its history and metadata. matrix.org logs device IDs, IP addresses and last connection times for up to 180 days. Element has proposed encrypting room names and topics, but the sources show it as a proposal, not a shipped feature.

Sealed sender
Show details

Sealed sender hides who is sending a message from Signal's servers, which still see the recipient and the connection's IP address. A phone number is still needed to sign up; usernames only hide it from other users.

Contact discoveryUsernamePhone numbers (hashed)
JurisdictionUnited Kingdom
Show details

Element Creations Ltd, formerly New Vector Ltd, is based in London and has subsidiaries in Germany, France and the United States. The Matrix.org Foundation, which runs the matrix.org server and the Matrix specification, is a UK Community Interest Company. A server run by someone else falls under the law of whoever operates it.

United States
Show details

Operated by Signal Messenger LLC; the trademarks belong to Signal Technology Foundation, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit.

TelemetryOpt-inNo telemetry
Transparency
Client codeFully open sourceFully open source
Server codeFully open sourceFully open source
Reproducible buildsNot specifiedYes
Independent security auditLeast Authority 2022
Show audit details

An audit of vodozemac, the Rust implementation of the Olm and Megolm encryption protocols that the Element X apps use through the matrix-rust-sdk library, published on 16 May 2022. Least Authority raised 10 valid concerns; 8 were fixed during the audit and the other 2 were left for later maintenance. The audit covers that encryption library, not the apps, the Synapse server or the Matrix protocol as a whole. Matrix said in 2022 that audits of matrix-rust-sdk would follow; none is published in the sources.

None on record
Past data breachYesYes
Architecture & features
Server modelFederatedCentralized
Self-hostableYesNot specified
Multi-deviceIndependent devicesNeeds primary phone
BackupsEncrypted cloud backupEncrypted cloud backup
Voice & video callsYesYes
Disappearing messagesNot specifiedNot specified
Funding
FundingMixed
Show details

Element sells subscriptions to governments and organisations for its server software and workplace app, and has raised venture money: a Series A in 2019 and a $30 million Series B led by Protocol Labs and Metaplanet in July 2021. The consumer app and the Community edition of the server are free. The Matrix.org Foundation relies on donations and on staff funding.

Donations
Show details

Grants and donations, plus an initial loan from Brian Acton. Signal's own November 2023 estimate puts running costs at about $50 million a year by 2025.

ReviewRead more →Read more →

Where each one is ahead

Element

  • Contact discovery: Username
  • Independent security audit: Least Authority (2022)
  • Multi-device: Independent devices

Signal

  • Cryptography & Protocol: rated 9.5 vs 7.0
  • Metadata Privacy: rated 6.5 vs 4.5
  • Group chat E2EE: All groups
  • Forward secrecy: Yes
  • Post-compromise security: Yes

Read also

Missing an app?

Tell us what you could not find. Every suggestion goes onto our list of products to review.

This opens a message in your email app, addressed to hello@privacypick.com. Nothing is sent until you press send there.