Icedrive vs Proton Drive Comparison
Don't see the tool you use?
| Feature | ||
|---|---|---|
| Overview | ||
| Rating | 4.9 | 7.7 |
| Pricing |
Show billing detailsHide billing details
|
Show billing detailsHide billing details
|
| Free storage | 10 GB | 5 GB |
| Lifetime plan | No | No |
| Established | 2019 | 2022 |
| Platforms | WebWindowsmacOSLinuxAndroidiOS | WebWindowsmacOSAndroidiOS |
| Rating by category | ||
| Encryption & Key Custody | 4.0 | 8.5 |
| Trust & Transparency | 3.0 | 7.5 |
| Features & Sync | 6.0 | 7.5 |
| Usability & Platforms | 6.5 | 7.5 |
| Price & Value | 8.0 | 6.5 |
| Encryption & keys | ||
| Who holds the keys | Depends on a settingShow detailsHide detailsOnly files in the separate Encrypted section are encrypted on your device, with Twofish and a key made from an encryption passphrase that Icedrive says never leaves your device; their file and folder names are encrypted too. The Encrypted section is available only on paid plans. Everything else, and everything on the free plan, is encrypted at rest with keys Icedrive holds, and Icedrive's servers convert those files for previews. Encrypted files cannot be shared. In the web app, encrypted files are decrypted in your browser with code Icedrive serves on every visit. | You hold the keysShow detailsHide detailsFile contents, file and folder names and thumbnail previews are encrypted on your device with keys generated there (OpenPGP, Curve25519). Proton can see creation and modification times, permissions, the username that uploaded each file and the size of the encrypted file. The web app receives its encryption code from Proton's servers every time it loads. |
| Also encrypted | File names only | File names only |
| Sharing | Shared files are readable by the provider | Shared files stay encrypted |
| If you lose the password | Data is lost | Recovery key you keep |
| Trust & transparency | ||
| Client code | Closed source | Fully open source |
| Server code | Closed source | Closed source |
| Reproducible builds | Not specified | Not specified |
| Security audit | None on record | Securitum (2022, paid for by the company)Show detailsHide detailsPenetration tests of the web app (September to October 2021), the Android app with its API (July to August 2022) and the iOS app (August to September 2022); no Drive audit report for the Windows or macOS apps is published |
| Jurisdiction | GibraltarShow detailsHide detailsIce Privacy LTD runs Icedrive from Gibraltar, a British overseas territory outside the EU; the terms say the service is controlled and offered from its facilities there. The company moved there from Wales in 2024. Icedrive's pages do not name the countries where your files are stored. | SwitzerlandShow detailsHide detailsOperated by Proton AG, Route de la Galaise 32, 1228 Plan-les-Ouates, Geneva. Proton's Drive security page says it owns its server hardware in Switzerland and Germany; the Drive privacy policy says its servers are exclusively in Switzerland, Germany or Norway. Proton discloses data only on a binding order from Swiss authorities. |
| Owner | Ice Privacy LTDShow detailsHide detailsIcedrive was launched in 2019 by a company in Wales. In February 2024 it announced a move to Gibraltar, citing the UK Online Safety Act, and became part of the Ice Privacy brand, which also sells IceVPN. | Proton FoundationShow detailsHide detailsProton AG's primary shareholder is the non-profit Proton Foundation, based in Geneva. Proton states it has no venture capital investors. |
| Telemetry | No telemetry | On unless you opt out |
| Past data breach | No | No |
| Features & sync | ||
| Desktop sync | Yes | Yes |
| File versions | LimitedShow detailsHide detailsNo versions on the free plan. Starter keeps versions for 14 days; Pro, Pro Extra and Pro+ keep them for 90 days. | ExtendedShow detailsHide detailsFree plan: up to 10 versions of each file, kept for up to 7 days. Paid plans: up to 200 versions of each file, kept for up to 10 years, with adjustable settings. |
| Collaborative editing | Not available | End-to-end encrypted |
| Review | Read more → | Read more → |
Where each one is ahead

Icedrive
- Price & Value: rated 8.0 vs 6.5
- Telemetry: No telemetry
Proton Drive
- Encryption & Key Custody: rated 8.5 vs 4.0
- Trust & Transparency: rated 7.5 vs 3.0
- Who holds the keys: You hold the keys
- Sharing: Shared files stay encrypted
- Client code: Fully open source
