PrivacyPick

Icedrive vs Proton Drive Comparison

Feature
Overview
Rating
4.9
7.7
Pricing
  • $2.99/mo100 GB, Starter for 1 year
  • $10.99/mo2 TB, Pro monthly
  • $8.99/mo2 TB, Pro for 1 year
  • $19.99/mo5 TB, Pro Extra monthly
  • $16.99/mo5 TB, Pro Extra for 1 year
  • $34.99/mo10 TB, Pro+ monthly
  • $29.99/mo10 TB, Pro+ for 1 year
Show billing details
  • 100 GB, Starter for 1 year: $35.88 billed yearly
  • 2 TB, Pro for 1 year: $107.88 billed yearly
  • 5 TB, Pro Extra for 1 year: $203.88 billed yearly
  • 10 TB, Pro+ for 1 year: $359.88 billed yearly
  • $4.99/mo200 GB, Drive Plus, billed monthly
  • $3.99/mo200 GB, Drive Plus for 12 months
  • $9.99/mo500 GB, Proton Unlimited for 12 months
  • $14.99/mo2 TB for up to 2 users, Proton Duo for 12 months
  • $23.99/mo3 TB for up to 6 users, Proton Family for 12 months
Show billing details
  • 200 GB, Drive Plus for 12 months: $47.88 every 12 months
  • 500 GB, Proton Unlimited for 12 months: $119.88 every 12 months
  • 2 TB for up to 2 users, Proton Duo for 12 months: $179.88 every 12 months
  • 3 TB for up to 6 users, Proton Family for 12 months: $287.88 every 12 months
Free storage10 GB5 GB
Lifetime planNoNo
Established20192022
Platforms
WebWindowsmacOSLinuxAndroidiOS
WebWindowsmacOSAndroidiOS
Rating by category
Encryption & Key Custody
4.0
8.5
Trust & Transparency
3.0
7.5
Features & Sync
6.0
7.5
Usability & Platforms
6.5
7.5
Price & Value
8.0
6.5
Encryption & keys
Who holds the keysDepends on a setting
Show details

Only files in the separate Encrypted section are encrypted on your device, with Twofish and a key made from an encryption passphrase that Icedrive says never leaves your device; their file and folder names are encrypted too. The Encrypted section is available only on paid plans. Everything else, and everything on the free plan, is encrypted at rest with keys Icedrive holds, and Icedrive's servers convert those files for previews. Encrypted files cannot be shared. In the web app, encrypted files are decrypted in your browser with code Icedrive serves on every visit.

You hold the keys
Show details

File contents, file and folder names and thumbnail previews are encrypted on your device with keys generated there (OpenPGP, Curve25519). Proton can see creation and modification times, permissions, the username that uploaded each file and the size of the encrypted file. The web app receives its encryption code from Proton's servers every time it loads.

Also encryptedFile names onlyFile names only
SharingShared files are readable by the providerShared files stay encrypted
If you lose the passwordData is lostRecovery key you keep
Trust & transparency
Client codeClosed sourceFully open source
Server codeClosed sourceClosed source
Reproducible buildsNot specifiedNot specified
Security auditNone on recordSecuritum (2022, paid for by the company)
Show details

Penetration tests of the web app (September to October 2021), the Android app with its API (July to August 2022) and the iOS app (August to September 2022); no Drive audit report for the Windows or macOS apps is published

JurisdictionGibraltar
Show details

Ice Privacy LTD runs Icedrive from Gibraltar, a British overseas territory outside the EU; the terms say the service is controlled and offered from its facilities there. The company moved there from Wales in 2024. Icedrive's pages do not name the countries where your files are stored.

Switzerland
Show details

Operated by Proton AG, Route de la Galaise 32, 1228 Plan-les-Ouates, Geneva. Proton's Drive security page says it owns its server hardware in Switzerland and Germany; the Drive privacy policy says its servers are exclusively in Switzerland, Germany or Norway. Proton discloses data only on a binding order from Swiss authorities.

OwnerIce Privacy LTD
Show details

Icedrive was launched in 2019 by a company in Wales. In February 2024 it announced a move to Gibraltar, citing the UK Online Safety Act, and became part of the Ice Privacy brand, which also sells IceVPN.

Proton Foundation
Show details

Proton AG's primary shareholder is the non-profit Proton Foundation, based in Geneva. Proton states it has no venture capital investors.

TelemetryNo telemetryOn unless you opt out
Past data breachNoNo
Features & sync
Desktop syncYesYes
File versionsLimited
Show details

No versions on the free plan. Starter keeps versions for 14 days; Pro, Pro Extra and Pro+ keep them for 90 days.

Extended
Show details

Free plan: up to 10 versions of each file, kept for up to 7 days. Paid plans: up to 200 versions of each file, kept for up to 10 years, with adjustable settings.

Collaborative editingNot availableEnd-to-end encrypted
ReviewRead more →Read more →

Where each one is ahead

Icedrive

  • Price & Value: rated 8.0 vs 6.5
  • Telemetry: No telemetry

Proton Drive

  • Encryption & Key Custody: rated 8.5 vs 4.0
  • Trust & Transparency: rated 7.5 vs 3.0
  • Who holds the keys: You hold the keys
  • Sharing: Shared files stay encrypted
  • Client code: Fully open source

Read also

Missing an app?

Tell us what you could not find. Every suggestion goes onto our list of products to review.

This opens a message in your email app, addressed to hello@privacypick.com. Nothing is sent until you press send there.