PrivacyPick

Malwarebytes Premium Security vs Surfshark Antivirus Comparison

Feature
Overview
Rating
6.3
6.1
Pricing
  • $5.00/moStandard for 3 devices, 1 year
  • $3.75/moStandard for 1 device, 1 year
  • $6.67/moPlus for 3 devices, 1 year
  • $7.50/moTotal for 1 adult and 3 devices, first year
  • $15.00/moTotal for 1 adult and 3 devices, renewal
Show billing details
  • Standard for 3 devices, 1 year: $59.99 a year; the store cart lists the same amount for the next billing
  • Standard for 1 device, 1 year: $44.99 a year
  • Plus for 3 devices, 1 year: $79.98 a year
  • Total for 1 adult and 3 devices, first year: Intro: $89.99 for the first year, a 50% discount
  • Total for 1 adult and 3 devices, renewal: $179.99 a year after the first year; the page says the discount is first year only
  • $8.25/moSurfshark One, renewal
  • $19.95/moSurfshark One, month to month
  • $2.49/moSurfshark One, first 2 years
  • $2.99/moSurfshark One, first year
  • $9.92/moSurfshark One+, renewal
Show billing details
  • Surfshark One, renewal: $99 a year after the first term, whether that term was 1 or 2 years
  • Surfshark One, month to month: $19.95 billed every month, no discount
  • Surfshark One, first 2 years: Intro: $67.23 for the first 27 months (24 plus 3 bonus months), then $99 a year
  • Surfshark One, first year: Intro: $44.85 for the first 15 months (12 plus 3 bonus months), then $99 a year
  • Surfshark One+, renewal: $119 a year after the first term
Sold on its ownYesNo
Free tierLimited free tierPaid only
Devices35
Money-back60 days30 days
Established20082021
Platforms
WindowsmacOSAndroidiOS
WindowsmacOSAndroid
Extras included
FirewallSystem cleanup
VPNIdentity monitoring
Rating by category
Protection Quality
7.5
7.0
Privacy & Data Practices
5.5
5.5
Usability & System Impact
6.5
6.5
Transparency & Verifiability
4.5
4.5
Price & Value
7.0
6.0
Protection
Independent lab testsRegularly testedSometimes tested
Lab resultsProtection 6.0/6 (0-day attacks 100% in July and 99.3% in August, industry average 99.9%; reference set 100% in July and 99.9% in August) (AV-TEST, Home user test, Malwarebytes Premium 5.5 & 5.6 (report 261412), Jul–Aug 2026, Windows) + 3 more6.0/6.0; 0-day and web threats 100% (May) and 99.8% (June), industry average 99.9%; recent widespread malware 100% in both months (AV-TEST, Home user security products for Windows (report 261317, version 6.9 & 6.11), May–Jun 2026, Windows) + 1 more
Privacy & data
What leaves the deviceFiles uploaded
Show details

The privacy policy lists, among the data its software collects, 'artifacts detected as malware, PUPs, or suspicious files' and, for blocked exploits, the exploit payload files and possibly a copy of the exploit executable. It says the content analysis of files, photos and messages runs on the device and the company does not receive the content, 'unless we describe otherwise for a specific feature'; one such feature is text message protection on mobile, which sends the sender and the body of texts from senders not in your contacts and keeps the malicious ones for analysis. It does not say whether the upload of detected files can be switched off separately; the opt-out covers 'threat statistics', which include detection samples.

Not stated
Show details

Surfshark says Cloud Protect checks suspicious files against its cloud database in real time 'without ever seeing your personal data', but neither the product pages, the help center nor the privacy policy say whether a file's fingerprint or the file itself is sent.

Data used forAds or partners
Show details

The privacy policy says Malwarebytes does not sell personal data for money, but that it may share limited information with advertising partners such as Meta to measure ads: a hashed email address, online identifiers, ad click identifiers and IP address. Meta and Malwarebytes are joint controllers for data sent through Meta's business tools. The policy offers an opt-out through 'Your Privacy Choices' on the website or Global Privacy Control. It also says the product collects usage and threat statistics, a machine identifier created at install, and IP-based location, but that it does not store the IP address of client requests.

Ads or partners
Show details

The privacy policy's antivirus section uses device information to enforce the device limit and processes the malware name and type, country, OS and user ID for statistics. Separately, with your consent, the apps send device and engagement data to analytics and attribution providers, and the policy says advertising partners help attribute sales and show interest-based ads. The policy says Surfshark does not sell personal data.

TelemetryOn unless you opt outAlways on
Past data sharingNoNo
Past breachYesYes
Trust & transparency
Product auditNone on recordNone on record
Bug bountyNoYes
JurisdictionUnited States
Show details

Malwarebytes is based in Santa Clara, California, and its privacy policy gives that address and says Malwarebytes Inc. takes part in the EU–US, UK and Swiss data privacy frameworks. The policy says the company may disclose personal data to government agencies in response to lawful requests, including subpoenas and warrants.

Netherlands
Show details

The contract is with Surfshark B.V., registered in Amsterdam, the Netherlands. The terms of service are governed by the law of the British Virgin Islands.

OwnerMalwarebytes Inc.
Show details

Founded in 2008; co-founder Marcin Kleczynski is still chief executive. In December 2022 the private equity firm Vector Capital closed a $100 million minority investment and two of its managing directors joined the board.

Surfshark B.V.
Show details

Surfshark B.V. sells the antivirus as part of its own subscription. The privacy policy says it shares data with its group companies in the EEA, the United States and the United Kingdom, without naming them.

ReviewRead more →Read more →

Where each one is ahead

Malwarebytes Premium Security

  • Price & Value: rated 7.0 vs 6.0
  • Sold on its own: Yes
  • Independent lab tests: Regularly tested

Surfshark Antivirus

  • Bug bounty: Yes

Read also

Missing an app?

Tell us what you could not find. Every suggestion goes onto our list of products to review.

This opens a message in your email app, addressed to hello@privacypick.com. Nothing is sent until you press send there.